'Treat everyone the same – differently'? How to handle discrepancies in discipline

Was Coach Jimmy Johnson right in his approach to disciplinary issues?

In this What's YOUR Problem video, Chief Goldfeder answers this question:

Can you address the issue of treating everyone the same with regards to infractions against policies and procedures? I remember Coach Jimmy Johnson saying, "I treat everyone the same – differently,” when he explained how he cut a rookie who fell asleep during a film session while he just nudged his star quarterback, Troy Aikman, to wake him up. I know there are pitfalls in not treating everyone the same, but the reality is, some members might have earned a break by how much they give themselves to the job. This is not to say that the issues aren't addressed; they absolutely have to be addressed, but maybe how they are handled is different depending on the member."

Do you have a question for Chief Goldfeder? Email editor@firerescue1.com or submit a question here.

Watch more What's YOUR Problem? videos here.

Improve the safety and effectiveness of your department and personnel with an online training solution from FireRescue1 Academy. Access more than 1,000 courses and videos, including more than 440 hours of approved EMS CEUs. With FireRescue1 Academy, training can be delivered during in-service, field training or in a self-paced format. SCHEDULE A FREE DEMO NOW!

Join the discussion

Copyright © 2022 Fire Chief. All rights reserved.